
Finally! The 29 track, double disc "Special Edition Deluxe" set with the new stereo mix by Giles Martin. Been waiting for this one since I heard the 2022 Special Edition of Revolver (some of this post is simply copied from that earlier post).
If you're looking for my earlier thoughts on the album plus the usual ads, CD longbox picture, album reviews, chart data, etc., please check out my 2012 post here: The CD Project: Rubber Soul. This post will primarily deal with the new mixes, bonus tracks, and packaging.
Like the other Giles Martin mixes, this stereo mix sounds fantastic. The individual parts are cleaner, separated, much easier to delineate. Back in 1965, the album was first mixed to mono; the stereo mix was an afterthought, which is one reason why many fans prefer those earlier mono versions:
There is an intensity to mono because it was mixed to blast straight into you from that one speaker. By contrast, the stereo separation diffuses the atmosphere in some songs and distracts in others.So this new mix not only benefits from technological advances, but also from a deliberate, concerted effort to produce the best stereo mix available. Now these cuts can "blast straight into you" in lively, rich stereo. It's a revelation to these ears even though they've heard these songs hundreds of times over the past decades. I mean it as a compliment when I say that I don't notice anything in particular about the demixes/remixes here, just that these familiar songs now sound even better.
If you prefer the mono mix, then by all means keep listening to it; it's not going anywhere. But if, like me, you grew up spinning an inferior stereo mix (first on vinyl then the original 1987 CD release), check out these new mixes; I count 10 different physical format options for you to choose from. FWIW, I like the mono mixes, too, and they'll be appearing here at some point in the future.
The 40 page booklet that came with the 2 CD set includes a foreword from John Lennon ("We finally took over the studio"), an introduction from Paul McCartney ("a very exciting album to make"), an essay by Beatles historian/former BBC radio producer Kevin Howlett, and lots of photos. Good stuff and all welcome in this house.

Tracks: I'm still blown away by the fact the whole album was written and recorded in just 4 weeks, October 12 through November 15, 1965. Makes me think I haven't done much lately. While all of these stellar tracks benefit from the remixes to varying degrees, my favorite new mixes are Drive My Car, Norwegian Wood, Michelle, and If I Needed Someone. And I hope to have In My Life played at my funeral. No hurry.
Bonus tracks: CD 2 is 41 minutes, 16 tracks. Mostly demos, alternate takes, instrumental backing tracks, and studio chatter; none of which interests me much. Still, I'm glad I got the 2 disc set, if only for the 2023 mixes of Day Tripper and We Can Work It Out.
Personal Memory Associated with this CD: Nothing and everything. "Everybody's born knowing all the Beatles lyrics instinctively. They're passed into the fetus subconsciously along with all the amniotic stuff." - from the 1998 movie, Sliding Doors.
Previously revisited for the blog:












